Car and Driver Best SUV 2024: Top 5 Picks You Must See

Why the 2024 SUV Landscape Is More Competitive Than Ever

2024 marks a watershed year for SUVs, with 60% of new vehicle registrations in the U.S. coming from the segment. This surge drives fierce competition, pushing manufacturers to innovate faster than ever before.

When shopping, consider that the average price of a new SUV has risen by 7% over the past three years. That’s roughly $2,400 more than in 2021, underscoring the importance of evaluating value and long‑term ownership costs.

Because of this, the car and driver best SUV list prioritizes not just upfront cost but also fuel efficiency, warranty length, and resale value – all key drivers of total cost of ownership.

Actionable Steps to Narrow Your SUV Search

Begin by mapping out your top three priorities: safety, technology, off‑road capability, or luxury. Assign each category a score from 1–10 based on your needs.

Use online tools like Kelley Blue Book’s “True Cost to Own” calculator to project yearly expenses for each model you’re considering.

Schedule test drives for the top two vehicles from each category to experience real‑world performance, cabin comfort, and infotainment systems firsthand.

1. Safety First: What to Look For

Modern SUVs now come standard with advanced driver‑assist systems. Look for features such as adaptive cruise control, lane‑keeping assist, and automatic emergency braking.

Statistically, vehicles equipped with a full suite of ADAS see a 35% reduction in rear‑end collisions. This data highlights the importance of safety tech in today’s market.

When evaluating, check crash‑test ratings from NHTSA and IIHS. A 5‑star overall rating is a reliable benchmark for family SUVs.

2. Tech‑Savvy Features That Add Real Value

True connectivity goes beyond Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. Evaluate vehicles that offer over‑the‑air software updates, voice‑activated controls, and integrated smart home controls.

For instance, the Tesla Model Y’s monthly OTA updates routinely add new features, such as enhanced navigation and improved energy management, without a dealer visit.

Google’s “Connected Car” report shows that 78% of drivers prefer vehicles with consistent, seamless app integration.

3. Off‑Road Capability vs. City Maneuverability

If gravel trails and rugged terrain are on your agenda, look for high ground clearance (at least 8.5 inches), independent front and rear suspension, and selectable driving modes.

Conversely, if you live in a dense urban area, prioritize tight turning radius and advanced parking sensors.

Statistically, vehicles with a 21‑inch wheel package, like the 2024 Ford Bronco, have a 42% higher traction efficiency on uneven surfaces compared to standard wheel sizes.

4. Luxury Features That Justify a Premium Price

Premium audio, heated leather seats, and ambient lighting are common, but true luxury includes adaptive suspension, head‑up displays, and gesture controls.

According to J.D. Power, customers who rate “luxury sound” highly are 5 times more likely to recommend the vehicle to friends.

When you assess a luxury SUV, ask for a 3‑day in‑house test drive to experience the ride quality and cabin acoustics fully.

5. Warranty and After‑Sales Support

A long powertrain warranty can offset higher upfront costs. Hyundai’s 10‑year/100,000‑mile warranty ranks among the industry’s best.

Check the dealer network density; a larger service footprint reduces out‑of‑home downtime.

Finally, review manufacturer’s recall history. A lower recall rate correlates with higher reliability scores across the board.

Putting It All Together: A Quick Decision Matrix

1. Rate each SUV on safety, tech, off‑road, luxury, and warranty categories.
2. Add bonus points for features that match your lifestyle (e.g., extra cargo space for families).
3. Calculate a composite score; the highest score should guide your final choice.

By following these actionable steps, you’ll transform the overwhelming SUV options into a clear, strategic choice.

1. Best Family SUV: Subaru Outback 2024 Review

The Subaru Outback 2024 consistently tops lists for family‑friendly SUVs, thanks to its blend of safety, space, and all‑wheel‑drive (AWD) capability.

Its 5‑seat layout is complemented by a surprisingly roomy cabin, where adults can stretch out without feeling cramped during long drives.

When the rear seats are folded, cargo capacity jumps from 32 to 75 cubic feet—a volume that can comfortably fit a full-size cooler, two strollers, and a bike rack.

Connectivity is a breeze: Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and a voice‑activated assistant keep kids entertained while drivers stay focused.

Actionable Tips for Parents

1. Use the rear‑seat entertainment system to stream kids’ favorite shows during school runs.
2. Set up Apple CarPlay shortcuts for navigation to school zones or playgrounds.
3. Pre‑heat the cabin on cold mornings using the built‑in climate controls via the touchscreen.

Key Family Features

• Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS): Adaptive cruise control, automatic emergency braking, and lane‑keeping assist help prevent accidents.
• Optional third‑row seat in the Limited trim expands capacity to seven, ideal for growing families.
• Standard heated seats and a rear‑seat entertainment package keep everyone comfortable and occupied.

Safety Highlights

• EyeSight Driver Assist Technology offers pre‑collision braking and traffic‑sign recognition, earning a 5‑star rating from NHTSA.
• Rear‑view camera with lane‑keeping assist improves visibility during parking and reverse maneuvers.
• Crash‑test ratings: 5 stars overall (NHTSA) and a 5‑star rollover score from IIHS.

Fuel Efficiency and Value

The 2.5‑liter four‑engine delivers 26 mpg city / 33 mpg highway, translating to roughly 15–18 cents per mile in fuel costs (assuming $3.50 per gallon).

With a starting MSRP of $28,000, the Outback offers a cost‑per‑kWh of 0.07 USD, comparable to competing midsize SUVs like the Honda CR‑V.

Owners report a resale value of 65% after five years, which outpaces many rivals in the segment.

Real‑World Performance

• All‑Wheel-Drive provides excellent traction on wet roads, cutting braking distances by up to 10%.
• Brake‑by‑wire technology ensures rapid response during emergency stops.
• The 4.0-inch sway bar improves cornering stability during family road trips.

Why It’s the Car and Driver Best SUV for Families

When evaluating the “car and driver best SUV” criteria, the Outback scores high in safety, space, and cost‑effectiveness.

Its all‑weather performance and robust warranty—10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain coverage—provide peace of mind for busy parents.

Comparative studies show the Outback ranks first in the “Family SUV” subcategory for 2024, according to Consumer Reports and J.D. Power.

Overall, the Subaru Outback 2024 delivers an unmatched combination of safety, comfort, and value that makes it the top pick for families seeking a reliable, daily‑driving companion.

2. Best Tech‑Savvy SUV: Tesla Model Y 2024 Evaluation

When you think of the car and driver best SUV for tech lovers, the Tesla Model Y instantly tops the list. Its all‑electric powertrain, clean cockpit, and relentless software cadence make it a benchmark in modern automotive design.

Thanks to the Dual‑Motor All‑Wheel Drive, the Model Y delivers a 330‑mile EPA range on a single charge. This figure places it in the same league as the Chevrolet Bolt EV, yet with the added benefits of a spacious interior and a higher safety score.

The 0‑60 mph sprint clocks in at 3.5 seconds for the Performance trim. For comparison, the Jeep Wrangler 4xe, often cited as a tech‑savvy rival, takes 6.1 seconds. This acceleration advantage translates to instant lane‑merging confidence on highways.

The heart of the cabin is a 15‑inch touch display that merges navigation, media, and climate controls. By eliminating physical buttons, Tesla streamlines the user experience and reduces distraction—a feature that earned the Model Y a 4‑point safety boost in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s latest study.

Software and Connectivity

Monthly over‑the‑air (OTA) updates keep the Model Y at the cutting edge. Each update can add new features, refine existing ones, and sometimes improve battery efficiency by up to 2%.

Smartphone key functionality allows drivers to unlock and start the car using their phone. This comes in handy for keyless entry, especially in crowded parking lots.

Alexa and Google Assistant integration mean you can control everything from your thermostat to your music playlist with a simple voice command, reducing the need to touch the screen while driving.

Charging Infrastructure

Tesla’s Supercharger network spans over 250 stations worldwide, providing a 250‑mile per hour charge rate. This network is growing at a rate of 10% per month, ensuring future coverage for long‑haul travelers.

Home charging with the Wall Connector delivers 11.5 kW, allowing a full charge in about 8 hours for a 60‑kWh battery pack. This is roughly 30% faster than the average OEM home charger.

Fast charging capability tops 200 kW, meaning the Model Y can gain 75 miles in just 15 minutes under ideal conditions. This makes weekend road trips less of a logistical challenge.

Actionable Tips for Tech‑Savvy Buyers

1. Prioritize OTA Features: Look for vehicles that regularly release software improvements, not just the latest hardware.
2. Check Network Coverage: Verify Supercharger or equivalent fast‑charging points along your typical routes before finalizing the purchase.
3. Explore Voice Assistants: Test Alexa, Google Assistant, and Siri compatibility during a test drive to gauge ease of integration.
4. Assess Battery Efficiency: Compare EPA range figures with real‑world data from owner forums to estimate daily mileage savings.

Why the Tesla Model Y Stands Out as the Car and Driver Best SUV

Its combination of high performance, exceptional range, and continuous software updates creates a living product that evolves long after the purchase. For tech enthusiasts, the Model Y offers a futuristic experience that can’t be matched by traditional internal combustion engines.

3. Best Performance SUV: Ford Bronco 2024 Breakdown

The 2024 Ford Bronco proves that power and precision can coexist, making it a standout in the car and driver best SUV lineup for adventure seekers.

Its removable doors and roof panels invite an open‑air driving experience, while the platform’s reinforced chassis delivers confidence on any terrain.

Under the hood, the 3.5‑liter twin‑turbo V6 churns out 400 horsepower and 400 lb‑ft of torque, placing the Bronco in the same league as luxury off‑road rivals.

For drivers prioritizing efficiency, the 2.3‑liter EcoBoost engine offers a 26‑mpg city/32‑mpg highway combo, shaving off fuel costs without sacrificing capability.

Ford’s Terrain Management System (TMS) automatically configures traction control, throttle response, and suspension settings for Rock, Sand, Mud, and Snow modes.

With a 0‑60 mph time of 5.5 seconds on the high‑output 3.5‑liter, the Bronco balances off‑road grunt with highway agility.

Off‑Road Capabilities

• 21‑inch aluminum alloy wheels with off‑road tires increase ground clearance by 2 inches.
• Approach, departure, and breakover angles of 30°, 22°, and 20° allow navigation of steep inclines.
• Integrated trailer‑towing package lifts 6,000 lbs, ideal for hauling gear or a small boat.
• Selectable 4×4 modes, including low‑range, give traction in rock crawl or deep sand.
• Integrated skid plates protect the underbody from rocks and debris.

Luxury on the Trail

• Upper trims feature premium leather upholstery with 20‑color stitching options.
• Heated, ventilated, and memory seats keep passengers comfortable during long expeditions.
• Premium 20‑speaker Bang & Olufsen audio system delivers concert‑grade sound.
• Wireless charging pads and USB‑C ports are available throughout the cabin.
• Optional 12‑inch touchscreen infotainment with SiriusXM satellite radio enhances entertainment.

Actionable Tips for Enthusiasts

1. Prioritize the 3.5‑liter twin‑turbo V6 for aggressive trails; the EcoBoost is best for city‑to‑outdoor commutes.
2. Install the Trail Trail‑brake control feature to optimize braking on steep descents.
3. Schedule a factory service every 12,000 miles to keep the 4‑wheel drive components in peak condition.
4. Consider the Hydraulic lift kit if you plan off‑road events that demand extra recovery gear.
5. Compare resale values: the Bronco retains ~60% of its MSRP after five years, outperforming many competitors.

Data‑Backed Performance Highlights

• EPA‑rated 0‑60 mph: 5.5 seconds (3.5‑liter); 7.2 seconds (EcoBoost).
• Fuel economy: 20‑mpg city/25‑mpg highway (3.5‑liter); 23‑mpg city/28‑mpg highway (EcoBoost).
• Torque: 400 lb‑ft (3.5‑liter) vs. 310 lb‑ft (EcoBoost).
• Maximum towing capacity: 6,000 lbs with the standard package.

By blending raw power, advanced off‑road tech, and premium comfort, the 2024 Ford Bronco secures its place in the car and driver best SUV list for those who demand performance and adventure in one vehicle.

4. Best Value SUV: Hyundai Tucson 2024 Insights

The Hyundai Tucson demonstrates that a smart price tag can coexist with premium features. Buyers who want a well‑rounded package without the premium price find the Tucson a standout.

At a starting MSRP of $28,000, the Tucson makes it one of the most affordable five‑seat SUVs with standard all‑wheel drive. The base SE trim already ships with a 10‑inch touchscreen, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and a suite of driver‑assist technologies.

Hyundai backs the Tucson with a 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty, a 15‑year/200,000‑mile corrosion warranty, and a 5‑star J.D. Power reliability rating. These guarantees translate into lower total cost of ownership (TCO) and peace of mind for long‑term ownership.

Future‑ready upgrades include a hybrid (HY) and plug‑in hybrid (PHEV) powertrain, giving eco‑conscious buyers a greener option that still retains the familiar Tucson driving feel.

Warranty and Reliability

• 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty – covers major components for a decade
• 15‑year/200,000‑mile corrosion warranty – protects against rust and body damage
• J.D. Power 5‑star reliability rating – industry‑top performance in durability

These warranties are among the longest offered in the compact SUV segment, setting Hyundai apart from competitors that typically offer 5–7 year coverage.

Statistically, a 10‑year warranty reduces the chances of major repair claims by 30% compared to brands with shorter coverage, according to a 2023 industry survey.

Trim‑Level Options

• SE – entry‑level with essential comfort and safety features
• SEL – adds 10‑inch navigation and upgraded upholstery
• N Line – sport‑tuned suspension, 18‑inch wheels, and aggressive styling
• Limited – premium leather, dual‑zone climate, and advanced driver aids

Each trim shares the same reliable platform, so buyers can choose based on feature preferences rather than mechanical differences.

Hybrid variants add 10 mpg city/12 mpg highway efficiency, while the PHEV can drive up to 30 miles on electric power alone. This makes the Tucson a versatile choice for city commuters and weekend adventurers alike.

Actionable Buying Tips

1. Compare trim features against your daily mileage: the Hybrid is best for short commutes, the PHEV for longer trips with access to charging.
2. Leverage Hyundai’s extended warranty as a selling point when negotiating dealer incentives.
3. Use the 10‑inch infotainment as a baseline; upgrade to the 11‑inch N Line package if you want larger displays without extra cost.
4. Schedule a test drive focusing on AWD performance in wet conditions to confirm the Tucson’s traction claims.

By keeping these points in mind, you’ll secure a Tucson that balances value, performance, and long‑term savings.

5. Best Luxury SUV: BMW X5 2024 Overview

The 2024 BMW X5 redefines executive crossover luxury, blending sport‑car dynamics with everyday practicality. Its chassis tuning delivers a ride that feels both planted and agile, a hallmark of the brand’s “Ultimate Driving Machine” reputation. Buyers seeking a high‑performance SUV that doesn’t sacrifice comfort will find the X5’s balance exceptional.

BMW’s 2024 X5 lineup now includes three powertrain options: a 3.0‑liter TwinPower Turbo inline‑6, a 2.0‑liter EcoBoost plug‑in hybrid, and the flagship xDrive45e that merges electric torque with a combustion engine for instant power. The hybrid version delivers 389 horsepower and 443 lb‑ft of torque, making it the most potent yet efficient version in the lineup. This figures into a growing trend where luxury SUVs average 300+ horsepower while maintaining fuel economy above 20 mpg city.

Inside, the X5’s cabin is crafted with premium materials and meticulous attention to detail. A double‑layered infotainment system—combining a 12.3‑inch infotainment display with a 10.25‑inch instrument cluster—offers seamless navigation and vehicle control. The 11‑inch touchscreen is optional but adds a streamlined look for tech‑savvy drivers. Wireless charging pads are now standard on all trims, eliminating clutter from charging cables.

Adaptive suspension on higher trims, especially the xDrive50i, automatically adjusts damping rates in real time, smoothing rough roads without compromising handling precision. This feature underscores the X5’s dual role as both a daily commuter and a weekend adventure vehicle.

Premium Features

BMW equips the X5 with a full‑suite Bang & Olufsen sound system that delivers 500 watts of power, delivering crystal‑clear audio across all speakers. Audiologists note that this setup achieves a bandwidth of 20 Hz to 20 kHz, catering to audiophiles and casual listeners alike.

The vehicle’s 11‑inch touchscreen includes gesture‑control capabilities, allowing drivers to adjust volume or change radio stations with simple hand waves. This reduces distraction and keeps the focus on driving.

A heads‑up display projects speed, navigation cues, and safety alerts directly onto the windshield, enhancing situational awareness. The system is calibrated for optimal brightness and readability in both daylight and nighttime conditions.

Performance Specs

Under the hood, the xDrive45e can sprint from 0‑60 mph in 4.4 seconds, a figure that places it among the fastest SUVs in its class. The torque delivery is instantaneous, thanks to the electric motor, which provides 480 lb‑ft of peak torque.

All‑wheel drive with dynamic traction control adjusts torque distribution between front and rear axles in real time, maintaining grip through rain, snow, or gravel. The electronic stability control also limits wheel spin during aggressive acceleration, ensuring safety in high‑performance scenarios.

BMW’s latest 2024 X5 also boasts a projected fuel economy of 24 mpg city / 27 mpg highway for the plug‑in hybrid variant, meeting EPA’s “green” SUV benchmark. This efficiency figure is 12% higher than the previous model year.

Actionable Buying Tips

1. Test the adaptive suspension by driving a mix of smooth highways and gravel roads; note how the ride quality adjusts.
2. Experience the Bang & Olufsen setup by requesting a demo session with a salesperson—listen to bass response and clarity.
3. Compare the plug‑in hybrid’s fuel cost against a traditional gasoline model; calculate potential savings using your typical mileage.
4. Ask about BMW’s 8‑year/100,000‑mile warranty on the powertrain; it’s a strong indicator of brand confidence.

Real‑World Value

According to Kelley Blue Book, the 2024 X5 retains 82% of its value after five years—ranked top among luxury SUVs. This resale appeal, coupled with low maintenance costs, makes it a smart long‑term investment for those who value prestige and performance.

6. Comparative Overview of the Top SUVs

While the table provides quick snapshots, translating those numbers into real‑world decisions requires a deeper dive into what matters most for your lifestyle.

Price‑to‑Performance Ratio

Calculating the price‑to‑performance ratio helps gauge value beyond the sticker price.

• Subaru Outback: $28,000 for 26 mpg city / 33 mpg highway, yielding about 1,300 miles per $10,000 spent.
• Tesla Model Y: $53,000 with 330‑mile electric range, equating to roughly 6.2 miles per $1,000—a high value for low operating costs.
• Ford Bronco: $29,000 plus off‑road gear, offering 400 horsepower and 6,000‑lb towing capacity for adventure seekers.
• Hyundai Tucson: $28,000 with a 10‑year/100,000‑mile warranty, ensuring low maintenance expenses over a decade.
• BMW X5: $60,000 with a turbocharged engine and luxury amenities, delivering premium comfort for business travelers.

Fuel Economy & Operating Costs

Running costs can outweigh upfront savings if you drive frequently.

• Subaru Outback: 26/33 mpg translates to about $0.12 per mile in gasoline at $3.50/gallon.
• Tesla Model Y: 0.2 kWh/mi electric cost averages $0.03 per mile in California, a 75% savings over gasoline.
• Ford Bronco: 20/27 mpg for the 3.5‑liter engine, costing roughly $0.15 per mile.
• Hyundai Tucson: 27/33 mpg averages $0.11 per mile, slightly better than the Outback.
• BMW X5: 19/24 mpg for the xDrive45e totals $0.17 per mile, higher but offset by luxury features.

Technology Adoption

Tech‑savvy buyers look for seamless integration and future‑proofing.

• Tesla Model Y: OTA updates every month keep the car cutting‑edge, adding new features like improved autopilot.
• BMW X5: The iDrive 8 system receives bi‑annual software upgrades, keeping navigation and infotainment fresh.
• Subaru Outback, Ford Bronco, and Hyundai Tucson: Offer standard infotainment but lack the rapid OTA cycles seen in electric or premium brands.

Off‑Road Capability

For those who love rugged terrain, specific metrics matter.

• Ford Bronco: 21‑inch alloy wheels, 33° approach angle, and 15.5° departure angle allow it to clear 30‑inch obstacles.
• Subaru Outback: AWD assists on light trails but lacks the high ground clearance of the Bronco.
• BMW X5: Trail‑ready packages add an off‑road mode, yet the SUV’s 70‑inch ride height is modest compared to the Bronco.

Warranty & Reliability

Long‑term ownership costs can be mitigated with solid warranties.

• Hyundai Tucson: 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty beats competitors, reducing unexpected repairs.
• Subaru Outback: 5‑year/60,000‑mile standard warranty plus optional extended coverage.
• Tesla Model Y: 4‑year/50,000‑mile battery warranty, critical for EV buyers.
• Ford Bronco: 6‑year/100,000‑mile limited warranty, standard for mainstream SUVs.
• BMW X5: 4‑year/50,000‑mile warranty, with extended options up to 12 years.

Luxury Features vs. Practicality

Luxury buyers often trade space for high‑end amenities.

• BMW X5: Bang & Olufsen audio, adaptive suspension, and a heads‑up display create a premium cabin.
• Subaru Outback: Focuses on safety tech and cargo versatility, offering 75 cubic feet of storage.
• Hyundai Tucson: Adds hybrid options and a 10‑inch infotainment screen for tech‑savvy families.
• Ford Bronco: Combines ruggedness with optional leather seats and a 12‑inch digital gauge cluster.
• Tesla Model Y: Minimalist interior, but the large touchscreen and glass roof provide a futuristic feel.

Actionable Takeaway

Use the table as a starting point, then overlay your personal priorities: budget, mileage, tech, off‑road needs, and warranty expectations.

1. Rank your must‑have features.
2. Match them against the column highlights.
3. Schedule a test drive to experience the feel and tech firsthand.

By combining the statistical snapshot with hands‑on experience, you can confidently pick the “car and driver best SUV” that aligns with your 2024 adventures.

Expert Tips: How to Choose the Right SUV for You

When hunting for the car and driver best SUV, the first step is to map out your daily routine. Think about what drives you: do you need room for kids, gadgets, or gear? This context will guide every decision from size to tech.

Next, align your budget with long‑term ownership costs. Even a high‑priced SUV can save money if it has lower fuel or maintenance fees. Conversely, a cheap model might surprise you with hidden expenses.

1. Define Your Core Use Case

Your primary activity will determine which model shines. Here’s a quick reference for common scenarios:

• Family travel – Look for roomy seating, advanced safety suites, and easy cargo handling.
• Tech integration – Prioritize over‑the‑air updates, smartphone key, and large touchscreens.
• Off‑road adventures – Choose high ground clearance, robust 4×4, and terrain‑management systems.
• Luxury experience – Focus on premium materials, adaptive suspension, and high‑end audio.

Matching these needs to the best‑SUV list helps cut down options quickly.

2. Compare Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

Use online TCO calculators that factor in depreciation, fuel or electricity usage, insurance, and routine maintenance. For example, the Tesla Model Y’s 330‑mile range means fewer stops, but its $53,000 price tag requires careful budgeting.

The Hyundai Tucson’s $28,000 MSRP and 10‑year warranty can lower repair bills, making it a cost‑effective choice over five years.

Don’t forget tax incentives for EVs or hybrid models, which can offset upfront costs.

3. Test Drive the Candidate Models

Assess real‑world performance beyond spec sheets. Remember to evaluate all elements that affect comfort and usability.

Test Drive Checklist

1. Check seating comfort for all occupants. Try the rear seats with an extra child seat to gauge legroom.
2. Evaluate cargo space with rear seats folded. Measure the height, width, and depth of the cargo area.
3. Test infotainment responsiveness. Open menus, connect a phone, and test voice commands.
4. Assess visibility and parking sensors. Park in a tight spot and check blind‑spot alerts.
5. Feel the steering and suspension. Notice how the vehicle handles bumps and turns.
6. Listen for unusual noises. Pay attention to engine or transmission sounds at idle and acceleration.

Take a 10‑mile drive in traffic and on a highway to capture typical use.

4. Verify Warranty and After‑Sales Service

Extended coverage can be a lifesaver. The Hyundai Tucson’s 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty covers most repairs and can reduce out‑of‑pocket costs.

Check the dealer network. A brand with over 2,000 service centers ensures you can get help anywhere in the country.

Look for complimentary maintenance programs. Some manufacturers offer free oil changes for the first year, which adds value without extra cost.

5. Leverage Consumer Reports and Safety Ratings

Consult J.D. Power and NHTSA ratings for realistic safety performance. The Subaru Outback’s 5‑star crash rating, for example, reinforces its family‑friendly reputation.

Read real‑world owner reviews. If a model consistently reports issues with door handles or infotainment lag, factor that into your decision.

6. Test the Technology Ecosystem

For tech‑savvy buyers, evaluate the full ecosystem. Tesla’s over‑the‑air updates deliver new features months after purchase, a contrast to conventional vehicle software.

Check Android Auto and Apple CarPlay integration. A seamless connection between phone and dashboard reduces distraction and improves safety.

Verify the availability of smartphone key or key‑less entry. These small conveniences can significantly affect daily usability.

7. Plan for Future Resale Value

Resale worth depends on brand reputation, trim popularity, and maintenance history. BMW X5 often retains 60% of its value after five years, thanks to brand prestige and high demand.

Keep an eye on depreciation curves. An SUV that slumps quickly in the second year may not be the best long‑term investment.

8. Factor in Environmental Impact

If sustainability matters, compare CO₂ emissions and fuel economy. The Tesla Model Y’s zero tailpipe emissions make it an eco‑friendly choice.

Calculate the life‑cycle cost: EVs may have higher battery replacement risks but lower fuel consumption.

9. Visit Dealerships for In‑Person Comparisons

Stare down the showroom lines and compare interiors side‑by‑side. Physical feel can reveal differences that photos miss.

Ask sales reps about real‑world fuel consumption and insurance premiums. They can provide localized data that helps you decide.

10. Make an Informed Decision

After gathering data, weigh the pros and cons of each model against your priority list. A simple scoring matrix can clarify which SUV ticks the most boxes.

Trust your instincts after a thorough analysis. The right SUV will feel like an extension of your lifestyle, not just a set of features.

FAQ: Common Questions About the Car and Driver Best SUV 2024

What is the best SUV for new families in 2024?

The Subaru Outback tops the list for first‑time families thanks to its proven safety record.

It earned a 5‑star NHTSA rating and received the highest crash‑test score in its class in 2023.

With a spacious cargo area that expands from 32 to 75 cubic feet, parents can pack strollers, sports gear, and groceries with ease.

Its all‑wheel‑drive system plus standard EyeSight Driver Assist gives parents confidence on any road.

How does the Tesla Model Y compare to traditional SUVs?

Electric power puts the Tesla Model Y in the same performance tier as gasoline rivals.

Its 0‑60 mph time of 3.5 seconds matches some high‑performance sport SUVs.

Inside, the Model Y’s 15‑inch touchscreen unifies navigation, media, and climate controls, eliminating physical buttons.

Tesla’s monthly over‑the‑air updates mean new features and improvements arrive without a dealership visit.

Is the Ford Bronco good for city driving?

The Bronco’s off‑road credentials are legendary, but city handling requires attention.

Its 4.8‑foot turning radius is larger than most compact SUVs, which can make tight parking challenging.

However, its removable doors and roof panels provide a unique styling twist that many urban drivers find appealing.

Choosing the 2‑door, 2‑row layout can reduce height and improve maneuverability in city traffic.

Can I get a hybrid version of the Hyundai Tucson?

Yes, the Tucson offers a plug‑in hybrid (PHEV) that blends electric range with gasoline backup.

The PHEV delivers an EPA‑rated 35‑mile all‑electric range before switching to hybrid mode.

Owners report an average fuel economy of 75 MPGe when driving mainly in electric mode.

This hybrid option keeps the Tucson’s 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty intact.

What luxury features are standard in the BMW X5?

The X5’s premium package includes a Bang & Olufsen 20‑speaker audio system.

Standard adaptive M suspension keeps ride comfort balanced with sporty handling.

The 11‑inch touchscreen supports Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and BMW’s iDrive 8 interface.

Heads‑up display, gesture controls, and a wireless charging pad elevate the cabin experience.

Which SUV has the best warranty?

The Hyundai Tucson leads with a 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty.

Its 15‑year/200,000‑mile corrosion warranty protects the body against rust for over a decade.

These warranties reduce long‑term ownership costs and provide peace of mind for budget‑conscious buyers.

Comparatively, the Tesla Model Y offers a limited 4‑year/50,000‑mile warranty on the powertrain.

Is the Subaru Outback still relevant with all‑electric competitors?

While EVs are gaining ground, the Outback’s 26/33 mpg city/highway rating remains competitive.

Its 245‑hp engine offers smooth acceleration for daily commutes and highway merges.

Subaru’s EyeSight system, available on all trims, provides adaptive cruise control and lane‑keeping assist that rival many EVs.

Owners can opt for a turbocharged 2.4‑liter engine to boost performance without compromising fuel economy.

How long does it take to charge a Tesla Model Y at a Supercharger?

A V3 Supercharger can add about 170 miles in roughly 30 minutes.

Charging times vary based on battery state and ambient temperature.

Drivers should plan for a 45‑minute stop to allow for vehicle cooling and a quick coffee break.

Tesla’s network of 250+ stations covers 95% of major highways in the U.S.

Can I tow heavy loads with the Ford Bronco?

With the optional Heavy‑Duty Trailer Tow Package, the Bronco can tow up to 6,000 lbs.

It includes a tow‑hitch receiver, upgraded cooling system, and a trailer brake controller.

Owners can also install an aftermarket 7‑tonne trailer hitch for additional capacity.

The Bronco’s integrated tow‑management system calculates payload and adjusts traction automatically.

What is the resale value of the BMW X5?

According to Kelley Blue Book, the X5 retains 67% of its original price after five years.

Premium features, low depreciation, and strong resale metrics make it a smart long‑term investment.

Owners can expect a base model value of $40,000 in the second year, up from $60,000 new.

Regular maintenance and the 10‑year warranty help preserve the vehicle’s value over time.

Conclusion

Why “Car and Driver Best SUV” Matters for 2024 Buyers

The car and driver best SUV list is more than a bragging tool—it aggregates expert data, real‑world testing, and consumer feedback. In 2024, SUVs dominate 61% of new vehicle sales in the U.S., underscoring the importance of a reliable guide. By comparing performance, safety, and value side‑by‑side, the list saves you months of research time.

Key Takeaway: Match Your Priorities to the Right Model

Every buyer falls into one of five core categories: family safety, tech‑savvy connectivity, off‑road adventure, budget efficiency, or luxury experience. The car and driver best SUV picks align each category with a model that consistently scores high in real‑world tests. For example, the Subaru Outback leads in crash‑test ratings with a 5‑star NHTSA score, while the Tesla Model Y tops the electric efficiency chart with a 330‑mile EPA range.

Actionable Checklist Before You Commit

1. Define Your Top Three Needs – Write them down. If safety and cargo are #1, the Outback or X5 are prime candidates.
2. Compare Warranty Packages – Hyundai Tucson offers a 10‑year/100,000‑mile powertrain warranty; BMW X5 offers 8‑year/100,000‑mile coverage. A longer warranty can translate to $1,000‑$2,000 in savings over the first decade.
3. Test Drive With Real‑World Scenarios – Simulate a family trip, a city commute, and a weekend off‑road drive if possible. Note how each SUV handles payload, acceleration, and infotainment response.
4. Check Resale Value Trends – Research the projected resale percentages. The X5 retains about 65% of its value after five years, outperforming the average SUV resale of 55%.
5. Factor in Running Costs – Calculate fuel or electricity consumption. The Model Y’s 1,500‑kWh battery equates to roughly $200 per year in electricity, compared to $400 for a comparable gasoline SUV.

Real‑World Data to Support Your Decision

• Safety – Subaru Outback’s EyeSight system reduces rear‑impact crashes by 30% in test scenarios.
• Technology – Tesla Model Y’s OTA updates reach 90% of owners within 48 hours of release, keeping software current.
• Off‑Road – Ford Bronco’s Rock mode lowers tire pressure by 20 psi, improving traction on uneven terrain.
• Value – Hyundai Tucson’s base MSRP is $28,000, yet its 10-year warranty can offset an estimated $1,200 in potential repairs.
• Luxury – BMW X5’s adaptive suspension adjusts 12 times per second for a smoother ride, enhancing occupant comfort.

Next Steps: Dive Deeper Into the “Car and Driver Best SUV” Guide

Visit each model’s dedicated page for full spec sheets, user reviews, and detailed comparison tools. If you’re undecided, book a test drive at your local dealership—most offer complimentary maintenance packages for the first year on qualifying models.

Remember, the right SUV is the one that aligns with your lifestyle, not just your budget. Use the car and driver best SUV framework to filter options, ask the right questions, and make an informed purchase that will serve you for years.