When you think of an old fashioned, you picture a smooth bourbon, a splash of bitters, and a single plump cherry. But did you know that the right cherry can transform that classic cocktail into a work of art? The best cherries for old fashioned are more than just garnish—they add a burst of flavor, a splash of color, and a hint of nostalgia.
In this guide, we’ll dive into the world of cherries that pair perfectly with bourbon. From traditional maraschino to fresh, tart berries, we’ll cover everything you need to know to choose, store, and use the best cherries for old fashioned. By the end, you’ll be able to pick the ideal cherry every time and impress your guests.
Why Cherry Choice Matters in an Old Fashioned
The old fashioned is a cocktail that thrives on balance. The bourbon’s warmth, the bitters’ complexity, and the simple syrup’s sweetness must all coexist. A cherry can tip that balance, providing a subtle fruity note that brightens the drink.
Choosing the right cherry affects the cocktail’s aroma, flavor profile, and visual appeal. A cherry that is too sweet can overwhelm, while one that’s too tart can clash. The best cherries for old fashioned offer a middle ground—sweet, slightly tart, and visually stunning.
Moreover, the cherry’s texture matters. A juicy, succulent cherry can release flavors slowly, enhancing the drink over time. In contrast, a dry or overly soft cherry may not hold its form, leading to a soggy garnish.
Top 6 Cherry Varieties for Your Old Fashioned
1. Classic Maraschino Cherries
Maraschino cherries are the go-to garnish for classic cocktails. Their bright red color and sweet, slightly tangy flavor make them a staple in bars worldwide.
Most commercial maraschino cherries are preserved in syrup, which gives them a glossy finish. While they’re convenient, the syrup can introduce a noticeable sweetness to your old fashioned.
To balance the sweetness, consider rinsing them in water or using a small amount of bitters to counteract the syrup’s intensity.
2. Luxardo Cherries
Luxardo cherries are a refined version of the classic. Made from real cherries, they’re preserved in a mixture of brandy and sugar.
These cherries offer a richer, more complex flavor profile. Their natural fruitiness complements bourbon’s caramel notes beautifully.
Because they’re less sweet than standard maraschino, Luxardo cherries provide a subtle contrast that elevates the cocktail’s depth.
3. Fresh Tart Berries (Pinks or Red Figs)
For a modern twist, try fresh tart berries like pink or red figs. These fruits bring a natural tartness that cuts through the drink’s sweetness.
Fresh berries have a delicate texture, so they’re best added just before serving. They release their juices slowly, allowing the cocktail to develop a layered flavor.
Pairing fresh berries with a splash of lemon or lime zest can create a bright, refreshing experience.
4. Sunkist Sweet Cherries
Sunkist sweet cherries are known for their deep color and juicy pulp. They’re harvested from the Sunkist brand’s orchards and are available year-round.
These cherries maintain a bright, ruby color even after preservation. Their natural sweetness is balanced by a subtle tart undertone.
When using Sunkist cherries, slice them in half to expose the pit, which can be replaced with a brandy‑infused sugar cube for added flavor.
5. Miller’s Black Cherry Cherries
Miller’s black cherries are a bold choice, offering a deep, almost plum-like flavor. Their dark hue adds dramatic contrast to an old fashioned.
These cherries are often stovetop-preserved in a sugar syrup, giving them a glossy finish. Their robust flavor pairs well with heavier bourbons.
They’re ideal for those who enjoy a richer, more complex cocktail experience.
6. Homemade Maraschino Cherries
For ultimate control over flavor, make your own maraschino cherries. Use fresh cherries, sugar, and a splash of brandy or cherry liqueur.
Homemade cherries allow you to adjust sweetness and preserve the fruit’s natural tartness. They’re also free from artificial dyes and preservatives.
Although they require a bit more effort, the payoff is a cherry that’s perfectly tailored to your old fashioned.
How to Store and Preserve Cherries for Longevity
Refrigeration Tips
Always keep cherries refrigerated. Store them in a sealed container or an airtight jar.
Adding a few drops of cold water can prevent them from drying out. For maraschino cherries, keep a small amount of their syrup on hand; it adds flavor and prevents dehydration.
Freezing for Long-Term Storage
Freezing is an excellent option if you plan to store cherries for months.
Place cherries in a single layer on a baking sheet, freeze until solid, then transfer to an airtight bag. This method preserves freshness and texture.
Using a Cherry Preserver
Cherry preservers are commercial solutions that keep cherries bright and juicy. They’re typically a blend of sugar, water, and natural preservatives.
Follow the product’s instructions for maximum effectiveness. A small portion of preserved cherries can be added to your old fashioned to enhance the drink’s visual appeal.
How to Pick the Perfect Cherry for Your Cocktail
Color and Appearance
Bright red or deep dark hues indicate ripeness. Avoid cherries that look pale or have brown spots.
For maraschino, a glossy finish suggests proper preservation. For fresh cherries, the skin should be firm and free of bruises.
Texture Check
Press the cherry lightly. It should feel firm yet give slightly. A too-soft cherry can burst in the glass.
For fresh berries, a slight resistance indicates juiciness. For preserved cherries, a firm texture is still desirable.
Flavor Profile
Fresh cherries should have a balanced sweet-tart flavor. For preserved cherries, taste a small piece; it should not be overwhelmingly sweet.
When pairing with bourbon, consider the drink’s strength. Heavier bourbons pair well with sweeter cherries; lighter ones with tart varieties.
Comparison Table: Cherry Types vs. Flavor Profile
| Cherry Type | Flavor Notes | Best Bourbon Pairing | Ease of Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Maraschino | Sweet, slight tart | Mid‑strength bourbon | Very easy |
| Luxardo | Rich, complex, slightly tart | Full‑bodied bourbon | Moderate |
| Fresh Tart Berries | Sharp, natural tartness | Light‑to‑mid bourbon | Requires fresh prep |
| Sunkist Sweet | Juicy, balanced sweet-tart | Mid‑strength bourbon | Easy |
| Miller’s Black | Deep, plum‑like | Robust bourbon | Easy |
| Homemade Maraschino | Customizable | Depends on recipe | Time‑consuming |
Expert Tips for Using Cherries in Your Old Fashioned
- Rinse maraschino cherries in cold water before adding them to the glass to reduce syrup sweetness.
- Combine two cherries: one for garnish and one inside the drink to release flavor as you sip.
- Use a cherry press to extract juice and add it to the cocktail for an extra burst of flavor.
- Store cherries in the fridge but keep them in a sealed jar to preserve moisture.
- Experiment with bitters: a dash of cherry bitters can enhance the cherry’s natural sweetness.
- For a vintage look, add a twist of orange peel alongside the cherry.
- Use a cocktail shaker to gently muddle a fresh cherry with bitters before straining.
- Try adding a splash of cherry liqueur for an extra kick.
Frequently Asked Questions about best cherries for old fashioned
What is the best type of cherry for an old fashioned?
The best cherry depends on your flavor preference. Luxardo cherries offer a rich, complex taste, while classic maraschino cherries provide a sweet, familiar profile.
Can I use fresh cherries in an old fashioned?
Yes, fresh cherries add a natural tartness. Slice them in half and place them directly in the glass for a fresh twist.
How do I store preserved cherries?
Keep them in a sealed container in the refrigerator. Add a splash of syrup to keep them moist and flavorful.
Do I need to remove the pits from maraschino cherries?
It’s optional. Removing the pits prevents accidental swallowing and allows you to replace the pit with a small brandy‑infused sugar cube.
Can I use cherry liqueur instead of cherries?
Cherry liqueur can be added as a flavor enhancer, but it won’t provide the visual appeal of an actual cherry garnish.
What’s the difference between maraschino and Luxardo cherries?
Maraschino cherries are typically preserved in a sweet syrup, while Luxardo cherries come from real fruit with a brandy‑sugar preserve, offering a deeper flavor.
How do I keep my cherries from drying out?
Store them in an airtight container with a small amount of syrup or cold water to maintain moisture.
Do cherries affect the drink’s alcohol content?
Only slightly. The sugar content of preserved cherries can dilute the drink, but the effect is minimal.
Can I add cherry bitters to my old fashioned?
Yes, a few dashes of cherry bitters can enhance the cherry’s flavor profile without adding visible cherries.
What’s the best bourbon to pair with a sweet cherry?
A bourbon with caramel and vanilla notes, like Maker’s Mark, pairs beautifully with sweet cherries for a balanced cocktail.
Choosing the right cherry can elevate your old fashioned from ordinary to extraordinary. Experiment with these varieties, follow the storage tips, and feel free to mix and match until you find your perfect pairing.
Now that you’ve learned the secrets behind the best cherries for old fashioned, it’s time to pick up a bottle of bourbon, grab those cherries, and shake up something unforgettable. Cheers to a cocktail that’s as classic as it is delicious!
